Assisted suicide, or, euthanasia, is the generally when a physician assists a patient who is terminally ill and wishes to die. Recently in France, there was a case of a woman who has a rare type of tumor that engulfed her entire face, making her eye bulge to 5 or 6 times it’s normal size and mutate her entire face. She was living with constant pain and the only thing she had to look forward to was death, as it was inevitable. The problem was she didn’t want to suffer until it happened, she wanted to die on her own terms, so she pressed the courts to change the euthanasia laws and to allow her doctor to assist her in her suicide by prescribing a lethal amount of drugs. After the court battle, the verdict returned as a no. The law would not change and her Doctor could not assist in her suicide. Two days later her body was found in her house, an apparent suicide, though the official autopsy is not in yet.
This incident has sparked much debate in France over euthanasia and it’s place in law. Currently it is still illegal, however; it is more of front line issue now and there are many debates taking place over it.
In Oregon, more than 300 people have killed themselves under the “Death with Dignity” law that was incited 10 years ago. The problem that occurs is the fact that those who wish to kill themselves with aid from doctors are not subject to a mental evaluation first. This leaves room for people who are depressed, but could be rehabilitated, to die.
Suicide is the choice of an individual to take their own life, I believe one should have the right to death if they so please. If someone wants to die, I do not believe it is unethical to assist them. I believe this because you are not causing harm to any non-consenting parties and in fact could be drastically helping the person who wants to die.
Dr. Kevorkian assisted in the suicides of over 100 terminally ill patients before he was arrested. I do not believe what he did was wrong. He advertised himself as a death consultant, and was contacted by terminally ill people who wanted to die, people who were sick of suffering and living in a hospital bed. He then put an IV in them, and they would push a button themselves, releasing the drugs that would end their own life. Kevorkian never forced anyone to do anything, never sought out people to do this to, they all came to him. He never killed them, as they pushed the button, ultimately, thus he assisted their suicide.
One could say; as a person, you gain certain rights, one of them being the right to live. If someone were to infringe on that right, without consent, such as murder, then that person has done something wrong. However, if one has the right to live, why then, can they not also have the right to die? There is absolutely no reason why anyone should not have the right to die. Someone’s life is their own, and though perhaps taking their life may be selfish, they have the complete right to do it, as it belongs to them. If someone is suffering, and wants to ends their life, there is nothing wrong with that. So if someone is suffering, and wants to end their life but hasn’t the means to do it, and another person assists them, there is also nothing wrong with that. I think it is wrong for the state to mandate what we do to our own bodies (so long as it doesn’t harm others.)
Dying a slow, painful death from diseases such as Cancer or Huntington’s disease does not sound very appealing. If one knows they are going to die, and it will be painful, and they will suffer, why wouldn’t they want to end their lives on their own terms, without suffering? Euthanasia; a painless death, A.K.A. assisted suicide is not something that should be illegal. When a terminally ill patient wants to end their life, why shouldn’t they be able to? If a doctor is allowed to stop treatment, why can’t they assist in a suicide? After all, stopping treatment is essentially assisting in a suicide, except the death doesn’t happen as quickly; instead it is painful and drawn out.
We all have the right to live, however; we all have the right to die.
http://www.lifenews.com/bio2370.html
http://www.koin.com/news/local/story.aspx?content_id=a02a1f99-3621-4b6a-8483-8e53f084df61

6 comments
Comments feed for this article
March 23, 2008 at 10:33 pm
fattmoosie
Interesting. It makes you stop and wonder though, if a person asks for assisted suicide, are they just trying to get out of the responsibility of doing it themselves? For example, if I wanted to be dead, I might ask someone to do it for me so that (while I was still alive) I wouldn’t have to feel as disgusted, as disappointed, as sad, and as guilty with myself for not choosing life.
Valid point about the “right to live, why not right to die?” I do agree with this, and I think I agree overall with your article. I just paused to wonder: Is assisted suicide just a way of passing on the blame?
March 24, 2008 at 3:41 pm
sunflowersutras
I agree completely. I saw that case regarding that French women recently, and was horrified that they would try to make her continue “life” in such a state. The right to live and the right to die are some, or should be, of the most basic rights. Dr. Kevorkian was someone to be admired for his bravery, and his true, unending dedication to his patients. I believe, however, that he did provide some sort of council to the ill; at least, I thought I’d read that.
I’m also gonna disagree with the above comment. Dying via an IV that has been administered by a doctor is a more comfortable means to die than, say, shooting yourself in the head. There’s also no “blame” to be passed along in such cases, as they are due to extreme illness. Unless, of course, you’re a religious person.
March 26, 2008 at 1:31 am
carrotherst
I am sick of you horrible people saying that assisted suicide is okay! How could you justify the right of basically taking another persons life! It’s cold hearted people like you why the world is so violent!
/sarcasm
Naw, honestly i really just don’t care about assisted suicide, i mean if they wanna die let them mugs die. Same thing with prisoners, in that movie Iron Jawed Angels I woulda let them starve. If you don’t wanna eat the food i give you go ahead, but when you bout to die don’t be complaining.
March 26, 2008 at 5:30 pm
Reggie
Completely agree with the right to die. Even if they don’t grant it, the people are either going to continue to just suffer, or will kill them selves on their own (as the French woman probably did).
It’s much better to have something set up so they can get assistance from a medical doctor. This makes it less painful, and less traumatic. A friend or relative who is aware of the person’s decision and can be present as they die will have much more closer than one who suddenly finds out their loved one killed themselves with no warning.
I also think there should be precautionary measures. A mental evaluation should be required first. One is usually given before something as mundane as most non-emergency surgeries, it should definitely be given before making a decision has huge as ending your own life. It also is a fail-safe to stop people from abusing the system, relatives or spouses who want to kill the person for insurance or because they’re sick of caring for them. I think that was the major sticking point in a few of the Kevorkian cases.
March 26, 2008 at 5:59 pm
ilikewar
I agree with this post. Assisted suicide should definitely be a law in all countries. Its your life, you can do what you want with it. If that means taking it, to end the pain, then it is fine with me.
March 28, 2008 at 12:18 am
mzleilae
I 120% agree with your post! Assisted suicide should be a law in all countires, but then you have to think.. are the people doing this “assisted suicide” actually have a reason 4 it?? But your life is simply your life, whther its to end the pain, or just to simply end your life because you may not feel its fr you its your life no matter how sad it may be. I do agree it should be a law!! Excellent post and VERY well written with good explanations:D